Can no longer search code without being logged in. · community · Discussion #77046
github.com
Select Topic Area Product Feedback Body This is revolting and an anathema to the open source movement. A movement, I might add, Microsoft is abusing here. We're told that this is for security... Bu...

Edit:

Since theres been some confusion with dates

In 2016 github made site side searching login only and hid the search bar if you werent logged in. This didnt include searching within a repository so that could still be done, just not all repositories

This year was the change being referred to in this link which made repository level searching require logging in

Blog post: https://github.blog/changelog/2023-06-07-code-search-now-requires-login/

  • towerful@programming.dev
    49·
    1 year ago

    I don’t know that “requiring a free account” is enshitification.
    Enshitification is the pursuit of profits at the expense of users and core experience.

    Sure, it’s annoying. Especially if I’m checking something on a random computer that I don’t want to log into GitHub with.
    But worst case, I can search on my phone then navigate to the file.

    • m_r_butts@kbin.social
      111·
      1 year ago

      pursuit of profits

      What non-profit motive do you think they have for requiring a login?

      • towerful@programming.dev
        21·
        1 year ago

        Right, and at the expense of who?
        You can’t just quote a small section of what I say, and “gotcha” me.
        How is this at the expense of users or core experience ?

        • m_r_butts@kbin.social
          4·
          1 year ago

          I’ll do one drastic, but not unthinkable, example. The Signal messenger source is on GitHub. You can’t imagine a single oppressive government out there that would be keenly interested knowing who in their country is interacting with it? Or maybe you haven’t noticed that there are a lot of countries not too keen on encryption, trying to backdoor everything or just straight-up outlaw encryption. This isn’t just about a single login box. “Who’s looking at what” is the kind of surveillance that blacklists thrive on.

          And please don’t come back with “then use a fake email”. Once you’re that far gone, you’re definitely breaking a user’s “core experience”.

          • towerful@programming.dev
            1·
            1 year ago

            I’m clearly using GitHub wrong if the search feature is that important.
            Just download the code. You don’t have to be logged in for that (that would be more of an example of enshitification). Then you can search it however you want.

        • averyminya@beehaw.org
          1·
          1 year ago

          Well for the experience of users, cookies/tracking/having to log in.

          Personally, I’m annoyed when I’m trying to do a basic function and am forced to log in. I’m not affected by this particular case with GitHub, but as a user where this happens elsewhere it is annoying.

          I’d be interested in the rationale behind the decision, asking your same question to them. Why do they need account login to search repositories?